SPIRITUALITY and METAPHYSICS HOMEPAGE

Quotes from Seth - What Is Spirit? - Links - What are Spirit Guides?

Seth and Jung: a Comparison in Quotes

An Astrological Critique of the New Age

See Also our pages on "The Metaphysical Jung" and Indigenous Homepage.
You are visitor number 11,150 + ( ) to this page, and number 11,150 + () to this site,thank you!
Please Return for Updates - Last  Updated July 2006

~Is Someone Just Imagining All This?~
~Creating Your Own Reality~

Creative Spirits

The notion of creative spirits which guide the manifestation of physical reality has long been out of favour in the West. The dominance of rationalism has led to even the churches shying away from a belief that the spirit which fires all material life is at large in the world uninhibited by attachment to the incarnate form or that the world itself along with its creatures has a soul or psychic aspect. But for more and more people now, the words of the songwriters and poets are ringing true again and, in the words of Leonard Cohen, "God is alive, magic is afoot!!"

As C G Jung put it:

"Life is the touchstone for the truth of spirit.
Spirit that drags man away from life, seeking fulfillment only in itself, is a false spirit - though man is to blame, since he can choose whether he will give himself up to this spirit or not.

Life and Spirit are two great powers or necessities between which man is placed.
Spirit gives meaning to his life, and the possibility of its greatest development. But life is essential to spirit, since its truth is nothing if it cannot live."

C G Jung "The Practical Use of Dream Analysis" (1934)
The Practice of Psychotherapy pg. 647
Once again a passion for life is awakening in humanity which knows the Love which enfolds us all and which can sing in celebration:

"Voice of the nova
Smile of the dew
All of our yearning
Only comes home to you

O Love that fires the sun
Keep me burning."

Bruce Cockburn/Golden Mountain Music/BMI

This presence of a creative spirit in the world, or a life force, is not just an amorphous `anima mundi' or `spiritus mundi' as some call it, a sort of undefined energy which animates the world. It is again being spoken that the creative force which gives rise to phyisical reality has the character of actual entities, such as the Dreamtime beings of the Australian aborigines. Gaia, or `Mother Earth', is no anonymous principle, she is a being with a will and intention which is celebrated in every expression of life which makes up this wondrous creation which we earthlings inhabit. And she is not alone. She is served and assisted by many other beings of all sorts who guide and assist all life forms, from the rocks and rivers and trees to creatures, and yes, even we humans. Though many of us have and still do deny this blessed guidance. We too are in her service.

Angels and Extra-terrestrials

The church once offered people a belief in guardian angels and the bible abounds with stories of encounters with such beings, but that time is long past. Even with the new upsurge in so called 'angel awareness' official sanction from the churches is not in sight, though many wonder and secretly believe. Although the connection may not be obvious the upsurge in belief in alien abductions and in salvation through the intervention of extra-terrestrial beings are related to the resurgence in interest and belief in angels. We may rightly question what this new 'awareness' is all about but we would do well to hold back from rationalistic dismissal.

The New Myth

Psychologically speaking such an upsurge, however apparently irrational, reflects an up-welling of material from the collective psyche relating to the need to re-establish a balance between the Yang and penetrating rational spirit which has dominated our age and the Yin and receptive orientation of more indigenous cultures. This represents the emergence of powerful mythic material in a somewhat inchoate form. At this time people attach this newly emergent material to all sorts of unexpected and even inappropriate systems of thought in order to give it form and find comfort with it. Thus it takes the form of "angels" or "extra-terrestrials", and occasionally faeries and other 'mythic' beings, because these are forms which enable people to find a relationship to it. That they are not necessarily 'true' in any provable physical or rational sense is not entirely the point, for as Jung says:

"Why should we deprive ourselves of views that prove helpful in crises and give a meaning to our existence? And how do we know that such ideas are not true? Many people would agree with me if I stated flatly that such ideas are illusions. What they fail to realise is that this denial amounts to a `belief' and is just as impossible to prove as a religious assertion.....It is the purpose and endeavour of religious symbols to give a meaning to the life of man."

CW vol 18 p247 para 566-7

These experiences of something out of the ordinary, numinous and beyond rational comprehension are all too real, hence the need of people with little or no framework within which to contain such experiences to reach for something, anything, to make their experiences meaningful. The belief in angelic and fairy beings reaches back into our past to find forms with which to contain these experiences in order to make sense of them. And the pseudo-scientific expression of these experiences via the images of extra-terrestrial abduction, space craft and salvation via the intervention of visitors from other star systems are part of this process too. Here making meaning of the breakthrough of these powerful psychic forces involves the attempt to couch them within the framework of the dominant 'mythos' of modern life, scientific rationalism. None of what is said here is meant to dismiss the experiences themselves only to suggest that they may be looked at more psychologically in order to render their meaning more fully and cogently.

Science as the Dominant Myth

The new church of science has been a great denier of the 'hidden reality' behind these experiences, hidden not by anything but our denial of sight. Many scientists are in fact religious people but mostly they keep their religious and scientific convictions as if in two separate compartments of themselves, although there are some who have dared to wonder aloud. This is the way we have been taught to deal with the "irrational". It must not be allowed to bring into question the hegemony of rationalism in defining the values of every day life. If it exists at all in the scientific mind it is as a factor beyond or outside the obvious material world and not immanent as a factor in the ongoing processes of change and development. Such a marginalised spirit is comfortably outside, not playing a part that might upset the applecart of belief in the ability of rational materialism to manipulate and control existence, sooner or later. Here-in we see how science at once marginalises the transcendent factor and then associates its powers to itself.

Science and the New Revelation

"No science will ever replace myth, and a myth cannot be made out of any science. For it is not that `God' is a myth but that myth is the revelation of a divine life in 'man'"

C G Jung, "Memories Dreams Reflections"

"I don't doubt that someday all our present cosmological notions will be recognised as myths. What we now think is science will in the future very likely be seen as myth - in other words as psychogical projection."

Edward F Edinger "The Mysterium Lectures"

Science has for a long time seen itself as the new revelation which has swept aside fear, superstition and mystery. And science seems uncomfortable with its new competition for popular belief and so works harder than ever at debunking things or providing ever more fantastic scenarios to capture our attention. It may not be accidental that there has been an upsurge in science borrowing the language of religion and mysticism to describe and popularise its newest theories. All this contains much denial of the reality of Spirit but does not make Spirit go away. It just forces many people to hide their experiences for fear of being labelled and dismissed, or to try to couch them in pseudo-scientific language. But more and more are coming out of the closet of denial which rationalist materialism has forced them into, claiming the knowledge their souls have never lost. Once asked what happens if we stop believing in the gods Jung said they become symptoms in our bodies. Indigenous cultures all have their versions of the presence of spirit beings both in the creation and continuance of the physical world. Some of these may be hedged around with fear, but nonetheless they have preserved the knowledge that we are never alone; that called or uncalled our guiding spirits accompany us ever ready to offer what guidance they can if we only ask and be open to it. Further to this, they preserve a deep understanding of the fact that we humans too have a vital role to play in creation, one which raises us out of the mundane and imbues our lives with meaning. In this our lives become part of what C G Jung called the 'Symbolic Life'. Amongst the greatest scientific minds the place of mystery is often still known. Albert Einstein said:

"There is no logical way to the discovery of these elemental laws. There is only the way of intuition, which is helped by a feeling for the order lying behind appearances."

Albert Einstein

and:

"The most beautiful and profound emotion we can experience is the sensation of the mystical. It is the sower of all true science. He to whom this emotion is a stranger, who can no longer wonder and stand rapt in awe, is as good as dead. To know that what is impenetrable to us really exists, manifesting itself as the highest wisdom and the most radiant beauty which our dull faculties can comprehend only in their primitive forms, this knowledge, this feeling, is at the centre of true religiousness."

Albert Einstein

It is the attitude of fear long associated with the irrational that needs to change, the fear of God and superstition that science rightly sought to challenge. But this need not be attained by the attitude that all mystery engenders fear, which seems to unconsciously underlie much of the scientific attitude. Unfortunately in this science seems to have thrown the baby out with the bath water.

Psychology and The New Revelation?

So a wave of new interest and what some are claiming as revelation is sweeping the globe but how can we know the truth of what is being revealed. There are some who claim to speak for what they call "Spirit" but who fall into traps of fear and negativity and a new superstition. One need only look at all the predictions of the end of the world which have failed but none the less lead countless thousands to live fear or its reverse, the rapture of awaiting salvation.

Fear is undoubtedly part of our experience of following the spiritual or religious path, or individuation as C G Jung called it, but that is because we do not want to let go and give up our attachments to wilful attitudes and egotistical control in life. Fear and destructive criticism are not engendered by a true relationship to "Spirit", God or Goddess, or what C G Jung calls the Self. The emotive reaction of fear invariably arises from psychological complexes which prevent our deeper alignment to the our inner lives or the spirit we serve. Our fear is because of our own attachment to being in control and the sense that a greater spirit at work in our lives would demand that we give that up, and it would!

As C G Jung puts it:

True personality is always a vocation....But vocation acts like a law of God from which there is no escape...He must obey his own law, as if it were a daemon whispering to him of new and wonderful paths. Anyone with a vocation hears the voice of the inner person: he/she is called."

C G Jung, CW vol 17 paras 299

The consistent avoidance of psychological approach by many who seek to follow the new "Spirit" always interests us. It is rather like the way many artistic people also seem to fear psychology. Such people seem to believe that a psychlogical approach seeks to explain away their experiences in order to dismiss them as aberrations of unhealthy minds. If one means mainstream psychology which would categorise and label, thus dismissing the experiences that is understandable. But the psychology of C G Jung does not dismiss the psyche but rather places it as central to human experience.

This Jungian approach suggests that it is always healthy to subject one's "inner voices" to a little psychological scrutiny, for their are many 'spirits.' that speak to us and we would do well to know from whom our advice is coming. If you go to a financial adviser, or an architect, or even a doctor these days, you may be well advised to check out her/his credentials, who may have influence with him/her that you don't know about and even seek a second opinion. Such scrutiny would only seem to be common sense. For many to subject the voice of "spirit" to such scrutiny is seen as scepticism and lack of faith but maybe it is just applying a little spiritual or psychological common sense. All the great spiritual traditions have systems of guidance and scrutiny for testing one's spiritual processes and this is not without good reason.

Psychologically this is equivalent to the understanding that one must be aware of one's personal and subjective factors, one's complexes as it were, in order to trust that what one sees as inner guidance is free of contamination from unresolved personal issues. Unfortunately many alternative or "New Age" people eschew all psychology as reducing the spiritual or psychic to personal psychological factors. This is of course a valid criticism of much of psychology but not all. We recommend here the views outlined in our Metaphysical Jung pages and the quote below about Jung's relationship to Philemon. We also especially recommend the book "Daimonic Reality" by Patrick Harpur (Viking).

Psychology which brings the source of "inner guidance" under some scrutiny is essential to psychic health and allows one to guard against bad advice as surely as it helps one to do the same when seeking worldly advice. Many a person caught in a 'get rich quick scheme might have avoided much anguish if she/he had been aware of the unconscious greed which drove him/her into it. Likewise some psychological insight might help many people to get their psychic yearnings into perspective and prevent them becoming caught up in misleading or inflated psychic scenarios which lead to manipulation by ohters. self delusion and ultimate disappointment.

The New Age and Commercialism

Unfortunately the populist commercialism of our culture all too often gets on the bandwagon of spirituality because of course the one rational value that can be found in the "irrational" is its marketability.

Hence the "New Age" has become a very marketable product and the rationality of commercial interest does not prevent it from beating up and selling the irrational, usually in its most banal and supersticious form, however well disguised. This of course, to use the psychological term, is the shadow of spirituality, a sort of base materialism which is justified by all sorts of clever rhetoric whilst remaining just what it is, rank commercialism.

What are Spirit Guides?

To begin here we offer a quote from C G Jung who we see as one of the path-finding spiritual explorers of the twentieth century. The modern offshoots of Jung's psychology, the so called Post Jungian movement, have strayed far from what that statement suggests in their reductive and anti-metaphysical approaches. However, the words of Jung himself ever ring with the depth of his striving to express the fullness of the human experience which always include the dimensions of spirit and soul. Jung's own experience with his guide Philemon and his coming to a deeper understanding of it are in part expressed in the following quote:

The Guru as `Spirit Guide'

"...a highly educated Indian visited me....and we talked about Indian education, in particular about the relationship between guru and chela. I hesitantly asked him whether he could tell me anything about the person and character of his own guru whereupon he replied in a matter of fact tone, "Oh yes, he was Shankaracharya.
"You don't mean the commentator on the vedas who died centuries ago?" I asked.
"Yes, I mean him," he said to my amazement.
"Then you are referring to a spirit?" I asked.
"Of course it was his spirit," he agreed.
At that moment I thought of Philemon.
"There are ghostly gurus too," he added. "Most people have living gurus. But there are always some who have a spirit for a teacher."
This information was both illuminating and reassuring to me. Evidently, then, I had not plummeted right out of the human world but had only experienced the sort of thing that could happen to others who made similar efforts." (emphasis added)

C G Jung "Memories Dreams Reflections" p184.

A spirit guide is a mentor or guru if you like those terms but it could also be something more. For those of us who accept a reality beyond the physical and psychological in its limited sense of arising purely from within the individual "mind" there are further possibilities. May be a spirit guide is a disincarnate entity which has chosen to guide and assist you in your life, like the early Christian idea of a guardian angel. These entities do not judge you and that is one of the ways you can tell whether its them or some negative inner voice which is talking to you. Your guides never speak with a destructive or negative tone even if they are suggesting ways you might do something better. They are always loving and accepting of you.

In the final analysis it does not matter whether we choose to believe one or the other of these explanations, our guides speak to us in many and sometimes surprising ways and if they aid us in living a more meaningful life they serve our wholeness and spiritual growth. They appear in our dreams, speak directly to us in meditation or in quiet moments during the day. The more quiet spaces we make the more likely we are to hear them. They are often behind positive intuitions which urge us to do this or that which turns out to be `just the right decision'. We all know those times when without knowing why we chose a certain path or did something we wouldn't normally do and it turned out well; that's no accident! We are guided in such matters, urged, encouraged and even sometimes pushed.

And sometimes with hindsight we even realise they were behind us not getting something we wanted but later realise would not have been best for us.

If you would like to offer us some feedback about any aspect of this site

Return to top of page?

Return to Ravenswood's Homepage

OR
Front Page Menu

Page Created 19 July 1996/© Rodney Ravenswood 2006

The background to this page is a statue of Pan, the great God of nature .